Reviewers consistently praise Addis Grill for authentic Ethiopian cuisine with carefully prepared dishes—particularly the Athenian grilled chicken, lamb kebabs, and teff injera—along with generous portions at reasonable prices. Multiple guests highlight the owner's friendly and knowledgeable service, the restaurant's improved atmosphere, and its convenient downtown location, though one reviewer noted that food took some time to arrive despite the wait being worthwhile. The restaurant has earned particular recognition for its vegan options, hummus, falafel, and bourbon selection.